Welcome to Isabella's Pizza
Isabella's Pizza, located in East Islip, NY, is a beloved gem known for its exceptional quality and delightful flavors. Renowned for dishes like the seafood fra diavolo and the revered grandma slice, customers rave about the generous portions and fair prices. Regular visitors appreciate the cozy atmosphere, which may be small but is filled with warmth and kindness from the owner, who is committed to the community. From flavorful pizzas to hearty pasta and delicious soups, every bite is crafted with care. Isabella's Pizza truly stands out, making it a top choice for both locals and newcomers seeking authentic Italian comfort food.
Isabella's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
They have THE BEST seafood fra diavlo & it amazes me it’s been the same price,especially for what your getting.I’ve been to fancy Italian restaurants & Isabella’s seafood blows them out of the water.The plum sauce is actually spicy and they don’t skimp on the seafood.I also love their grandma slice,I recently moved about 25 minutes away but I’ll still take the drive just for that slice. The owner is a very kind man that I’ve seen feed homeless and I love that their prices are so fair for food that remains good quality.Highly recommend Isabella’s!
I kept going for pizza alone and most recently started trying the various pasta dishes. There are so many other places in the surrounding area that are well known with a lot more space for indoor dining. I would hands down choose Isabella's for the amount of food you receive and the taste (small space to dine in, but we do take out). My son is a bit of an Italian food addict and we were trying different places to keep it interesting. I just can't believe how good the food is and the price at Isabella's. Why go out of my way to try other places when I have found our favorite? To be continued with more pics as I make my way through the menu....today we got 2 regular, 1 buffalo, chicken Florentine with spinach and kids chicken parm with spaghetti. The bread that comes with the pasta dishes is amazing! There is no need for garlic knots I'd you get this bread.
Not only the best pizza but their soups and burgers are delicious! Food always fresh too.
First time trying them. Everything was amazing. One of the best buffalo chicken rolls I've had. Wife got a insalata caprese salad which she loved. meatball Parm hero fantastic. Also got a personal specialty pie which was great. No complaints. (that was bbq chicken). Will get again.
Unbelievable I grew up in ozone Park and this is the best grandma I ever had and I’ve been to tons of pizzerias all over the island and Queens, New York by far the best I will not go anywhere else. Please try that grandma.
Clean, comfortable, friendly, delicious! This was a great surprise for us in a new neighborhood after a baseball game. Wish I lived closer...The Brooklyn slice was perfect and my son loved the Buffalo. The crusts were perfect crusty chewy.
Isabella's Pizza is a must in the Islip area. Great spot next to a pub. Love every slice, garlic knots and fried oreos. Excellent customer service.
Grandma slice was amazing. The sauce is pretty much perfect. Lil sweet, lil tangy . The crust is super delic! Check em out if you're in the area.
Location
-
142 Connetquot Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, United States Hotline: +1 631-224-2699
Welcome to the charming world of Isabella's Pizza, a beloved local gem nestled at 142 Connetquot Ave, East Islip, NY 11730. Renowned for its comforting atmosphere and delectable offerings, Isabella's is more than just a pizza place; it’s a culinary haven for those with a penchant for authentic Italian flavor.
From the very first bite, you'll discover why diners rave about their seafood fra diavolo. Customers like 'N G' have proclaimed it the best they'll find, particularly praising its generous seafood portions and the perfect balance of spicy plum sauce that ignites the senses. This dish exemplifies the commitment to quality that Isabella's embodies, challenging even the finest Italian restaurants.
But it doesn't stop at seafood. The famed grandma slice has garnered a cult following, as 'Vashti Persad' discovered when she found herself consistently drawn to this classic offering. Even a 25-minute drive can't deter loyal customers from indulging in the hearty slices that come laden with flavor.
Beyond pizza, Isabella's menu is a treasure trove of Italian cuisine. The pasta dishes, including the chicken Florentine, shine with fresh ingredients, accompanied by bread that could easily stand alone as a highlight of the meal. Patrons have lauded the meatball Parm hero and buffalo chicken rolls, perfectly showcasing the rich variety available. As 'Brandon Billings' experienced, every dish is prepared with care, resulting in a delightful palette of flavors that even the pickiest eaters will adore.
Isabella's Pizza stands as a testament to the love and dedication poured into each meal, backed by the heartwarming kindness of its owner, who goes beyond just serving food. The restaurant's commitment to community and fairness in pricing makes it not just a dining destination but a cornerstone of the East Islip community.
With every visit, you’re not only treated to fantastic food but a sense of belonging. So whether you’re opting for takeout or dining in the inviting, albeit small, space, Isabella's Pizza promises an experience that will linger in your memories well beyond the last bite. Highly recommended for anyone craving an exceptional blend of flavor, quality, and honest prices!